In the event that the reader has not seen the excellent New York magazine article Burning Down The House written by Steve Fishman about the last months of Lehman Brothers, go read it now. The sub-title is "Is Lehman CEO Dick Fuld the true villain in the collapse of Wall Street, or is he being sacrificed for the sins of his peers?"
Toomre Capital Markets LLC ("TCM") believes that this is one of the better articles that explains some of what went on behind the scenes that led to the collapse of the fourth largest investment bank in September 2008. Lars Toomre at one point worked with or reported to some of the principal characters of this story. Several reporters have contacted Lars for information and background information on these characters. However, other than sharing some recollections about Bart McDade with the Wall Street Journal, Lars has declined. Rather TCM has written a number of articles about Lehman Brothers (including the very popular post Possible Bankruptcy for Joe Gregory of Lehman Brothers). An index of the various Lehman Brothers articles can be found here.
This article starts out with a description of a luncheon meeting that Dick Fuld had in June 2008 with a number of investment bankers that was arranged by the head of investment banking head Hugh Skip McGee. Two days earlier the investment bank had announced its first quarterly loss in fourteen years. The loss of $2.8 billion caused the stock to plummet again, 21 percent in a couple of days. The message to Dick Fuld was simple: "The board of directors is going to be under pressure. … It has to deliver a head to the street." Supposedly Dick Fuld shot back (as his veins on his neck popped), "I've given you fourteen years of earnings. I have one bad quarter. This is how you respond?" Yet the next day he canned both the then CFO Erin Callan and his long-time crony and then COO and President Joe Gregory.
Three months after that luncheon, Lehman Brothers on September 15 "filed for bankruptcy, the largest in history and a devastating blow to an already fragile financial system. Fuld became a symbol of failure, the face of arrogant, blindered, massively overleveraged Wall Street. Fuld is blamed for betting the farm on the way up, then stubbornly refusing to recognize the company’s dire straits on the way down. A few weeks after the bankruptcy, Congress summoned him to Washington for a deeply humiliating inquisition." Subsequently, "three sets of prosecutors launched investigations of Fuld and Lehman, probing whether shareholders had been duped."
The article goes on to make the point that in some sense Dick Fuld also is a victim. Apparently Fuld has been having trouble sleeping as he repeatedly goes over and tries to decipher the "mystery", his description of the firm's sudden collapse. "Why didn’t the government save Lehman the way it saved so many others, Bear Stearns and AIG and, just last week, Citigroup? Fuld and his allies can’t help but blame Paulson, whom he’d trusted and, until the end, viewed as an ally and even a friend. Yet Paulson, for reasons Fuld doesn’t yet understand, participated in making him the scapegoat." However, apparently "Mostly, he sits and replays Lehman’s calamitous end. 'What could I have done differently?' he thinks. 'In certain conversations, what should I have said, what could I have done?' How, he wonders, did it all go so disastrously wrong?"
Toomre Capital Markets LLC might suggest that Dick Fuld made the critical mistake of trusting too much his protégé and the firm's Mr. Inside Joe Gregory. TCM has previously written about Joe Gregory's decision to remove Michael Gelband in the spring of 2007 as the global head of the fixed-income division in the post Initial Reflections on Demise of Lehman Brothers. Apparently, Gregory did not want to cut back on the fixed-income's risk profile and may in fact have wanted to expand the risk to use the resulting profits to further fund the firm's aggressive overseas expansion.